Who Decides Whether a Franchise Agreement Continues as Its Expiry Date Approaches?
The period leading up to expiry is one of the most overlooked stages in managing a franchise agreement. The franchisor focuses on expansion, opening new outlets, and monitoring daily performance, only to discover a few months before expiry that the franchisee has a statutory right to renewal, that refusing renewal requires specific grounds, and that an agreement it expected to end may continue for several more years.
The question that was never asked at signing is this: What happens when the agreement expires? Is renewal a franchisee’s right, a franchisor’s decision, or a matter for fresh negotiations?
Is Renewal of a Franchise Agreement Automatic?
A franchisee wishing to renew or extend the agreement must give the franchisor written notice at least 180 days before its expiry date. The agreement is renewed or extended for a term equivalent to the agreed term and on similar terms, except in specified circumstances.
This rule has a dual effect. On the one hand, it gives the franchisee a statutory right to renewal. If the franchisee meets the conditions, gives the required notice, and none of the exceptions applies, the agreement is renewed on similar terms. The franchisor cannot refuse renewal merely because it no longer wishes to continue the relationship.
On the other hand, this right is not absolute. The Law establishes conditions and exceptions that protect the franchisor from having to continue a relationship that is no longer suitable.
A qualification many companies overlook is the phrase “unless the franchise agreement provides otherwise.” This allows the parties to agree on a different renewal arrangement. A company that wants renewal to remain at its discretion, rather than being a franchisee’s right, can expressly provide for this in the agreement. A company that wants automatic renewal to apply only once can also specify that. The contract governs the position alongside the default rule.
When May the Franchisee Request Renewal?
The right to request renewal must be exercised within a specific timeframe. Notice must be sent at least 180 days before expiry. This is more than a procedural detail. A franchisee that sends notice 170 days before expiry has not validly exercised that right, and the Law does not require the franchisor to accept late notice.
The timing serves a practical purpose. The franchisor needs sufficient time to assess the franchisee’s performance, review its obligations, confirm that it meets the conditions, and negotiate any amendments. The 180-day period gives the franchisor an opportunity to make an informed decision. A franchisor that learns of the franchisee’s wish to renew only two months before expiry has insufficient time to conduct a proper assessment.
The Law also includes a condition concerning the conclusion of the renewal agreement itself. Even if the franchisee gives notice on time, it must conclude the renewal or extension agreement in accordance with the franchisor’s reasonable requirements at least 60 days before the existing agreement expires.
Notice alone is therefore insufficient. It must be followed by actual contractual steps. A franchisee that gives notice and then ignores negotiations or the franchisor’s reasonable requirements may lose its renewal right despite having submitted notice on time.
The franchisor’s reasonable requirements are not unlimited. They are requirements connected to the nature of the relationship, such as updating financial information, submitting an operating plan, or meeting agreed operational conditions. They do not include arbitrary requirements intended to obstruct renewal without a genuine reason.
When May the Franchisor Refuse Renewal?
The Law specifies six circumstances in which the automatic renewal rule may be displaced. These provide grounds on which the franchisor may rely to refuse renewal without exposing that refusal to challenge.
The first is where the franchisor and franchisee agree on new terms. This does not amount to refusing renewal; it means that the parties have chosen to amend the agreement instead of renewing it on its original terms. The changes may concern scope, fees, or duration. By agreeing on new terms, the parties enter into fresh negotiations rather than using the automatic renewal mechanism.
The second is where a circumstance specified by the Law as a legitimate ground for termination arises. This connects renewal to the termination rules. If there is a legitimate ground for terminating the agreement before expiry, there is all the more reason to refuse renewal. Legitimate grounds for termination include a material breach that remains unremedied for 14 days after written notice, repeated non-compliance following written notice, material violations that adversely affect the reputation of the franchise business, or an act of commercial fraud.
The third is the franchisee’s failure to pay amounts due under the franchise agreement. A franchisee that has not paid the agreed fees cannot demand renewal. The practical question, however, is whether this covers any overdue amount or only material amounts. The Law does not specify a threshold, but judicial practice tends to consider the seriousness and scale of the delay. A small overdue amount may not justify refusing renewal, particularly if the franchisee is willing to pay it.
The fourth is where the franchisor approves the franchisee’s assignment of the agreement to a person who meets the relevant criteria. This means that the franchisee has chosen assignment instead of renewal. Once the franchisor approves the assignment, the agreement passes to the assignee, and renewal is unnecessary.
The fifth is where the franchisor no longer wishes to operate the franchise business or grant franchises for it in Saudi Arabia. This gives the franchisor an exit if it decides to withdraw entirely from the Saudi market. It does not permit a partial withdrawal or a reduction in the number of franchisees. The decision must apply generally rather than selectively.
The sixth is the franchisee’s failure to conclude the renewal or extension agreement in accordance with the franchisor’s reasonable requirements at least 60 days before expiry. This concerns procedure rather than substantive eligibility. A franchisee that gives notice on time but fails to conclude the renewal agreement by the deadline may lose its right. A franchisor that requests additional documents or information which the franchisee fails to provide on time may rely on this ground.
What Should the Company Do Before the Agreement Expires?
Managing renewal begins on the first day of the agreement, not 180 days before expiry. A franchisor that does not keep performance records, monitor the franchisee’s obligations, or document breaches will be in a difficult position when renewal is requested because it has no documented grounds for refusal.
The first step is to review the agreement itself. Does it establish a renewal arrangement that differs from the default rule? Does it give the franchisee an unconditional renewal right? Does it specify requirements for concluding the renewal? The answers determine whether the franchisor has room to exercise discretion or whether renewal is an established entitlement.
The second step is to assess the franchisee’s performance before it requests renewal. The franchisor needs a file documenting the franchisee’s obligations, inspection reports, sales records, and outstanding payments. Any breach must be clearly recorded in writing rather than based on an impression.
The third step is to decide before the deadline expires. If the franchisor intends to refuse renewal, it should communicate its refusal in writing, stating the reasons, sufficiently ahead of expiry. The Law does not specify a deadline for the franchisor’s refusal, but sound contractual practice calls for a response that gives the franchisee time to make arrangements. A franchisor that waits until the final week and then refuses renewal without documented grounds creates the potential for an unexpected dispute.
Practical Takeaways
Renewal is a strategic decision that determines the future of the relationship. The Law gives the franchisee a conditional right to renewal, not an absolute one. A franchisor wishing to retain discretion over renewal needs an agreement that expressly provides for it, ongoing documentation of the franchisee’s performance, and a timely decision.
Before any franchise agreement expires, your company should ask more than whether it wants to renew. Does it have documented grounds for its decision, whether to renew or refuse? And how long can it delay before the outcome is effectively imposed on it?
Frequently Asked Questions
How Far in Advance Must the Franchisee Give Notice of Its Intention to Renew?
At least 180 days before the agreement’s expiry date.
The Law requires a franchisee wishing to renew or extend the agreement to give the franchisor written notice at least 180 days before expiry. Late notice does not oblige the franchisor to renew.
Is Renewal a Franchisee’s Right or a Franchisor’s Decision?
It is a conditional right of the franchisee unless the agreement provides otherwise.
The Law gives the franchisee a right to renewal on similar terms if it meets the notice requirements and its obligations, subject to specified exceptions. However, the agreement may establish a different renewal arrangement. The parties may therefore agree that renewal is discretionary rather than automatic.
When May the Franchisor Refuse Renewal?
There are six circumstances: agreement on new terms, the existence of a legitimate ground for termination, failure to pay amounts due, assignment to a qualifying person, the franchisor’s decision to cease operating the business in Saudi Arabia, and failure to conclude the renewal agreement at least 60 days before expiry.
These are the grounds on which the franchisor may rely to refuse renewal. A refusal outside these circumstances may be challenged.
What Happens If the Franchisee Gives Notice on Time but Does Not Conclude the Renewal Agreement Before Expiry?
It may lose its right to renewal.
Failure to conclude the renewal or extension agreement in accordance with the franchisor’s reasonable requirements at least 60 days before expiry is a statutory exception to renewal. Notice alone is insufficient; it must be followed by the conclusion of the agreement.
Can the Franchisor Refuse Renewal Simply Because It No Longer Wishes to Continue the Relationship?
No, except where the statutory provision concerning its decision to cease operating the franchise business in Saudi Arabia applies.
Refusal requires one of the specified grounds. A personal preference to discontinue the relationship is insufficient unless the franchisor intends to withdraw entirely from the Saudi market. Refusing renewal without legitimate grounds exposes the refusal to challenge.


